By Kyle J. Hayes
I know some of you are already sharpening your knives.
I’ve come ready to fight because Fleetwood Mac’s “Rumours” is on the list, and I don’t believe it deserves to be. There, I said it. And I stand by it.
Look, I get it. Rumours is one of those sacred cows of rock and roll. The kind of album people mention in hushed, reverent tones as if saying it’s less than a masterpiece is blasphemy. It has sold millions. It is beloved. It is a soundtrack to breakups and breakdowns, a cornerstone of ’70s rock.
And yet—
For an album that is supposed to be so emotionally charged, so soaked in heartbreak and betrayal, why does it feel so safe? Rumours never really cuts deep, never really digs beneath the surface. It’s clean—almost too clean. The music is pleasant, the lyrics are easy to follow, and the message is clear. And maybe that’s precisely the problem.
Simple music. Simple lyrics. Simple message.
That doesn’t make it bad. It makes it OK. But great? Top-tier? One of the best albums ever made? That’s where I tap out.
As a band, Fleetwood Mac has always felt a little overrated to me—better than average, but not by much. And this album, for all its polish, does not move me the way an excellent record should. It does not challenge. It does not provoke. It does not force me to wrestle with something bigger than myself. It is digestible and easy to listen to for people who want the illusion of pain without having to sit in it for too long.
Before you come for me, let me be clear—I don’t hate this album. It has its moments. Dreams is iconic. Go Your Own Way is an anthem. And sure, The Chain is a solid track with its steady build and brooding intensity. But these are moments, not revelations. This is a good record—maybe even an excellent pop-rock record—but an all-time great album? That’s another level entirely.
And for me, Rumours, just doesn’t get there.
People will say, “But it’s about the band’s real-life turmoil! They were falling apart! The emotion is real!” And sure, the context is dramatic. However, context does not always translate into depth. An album isn’t great just because it was born out of chaos—it’s great when it feels like chaos. When it bleeds on the floor. When it forces you into its world, whether you like it or not.
Rumours never did that for me.
So yes, it’s OK. It’s catchy. It’s well-produced. But does it belong at the top of rock and roll’s greatest albums?
Not in my book… You may now bring out the Pitchforks.


